[6] See State v. Vilvarajah, 735 S.W.2d 837, 839 (Tenn. Crim. U.S., Newspapers.com Obituary Index, 1800s-current. Resend Activation Email. Find Karen Pulley obituaries and memorials at Legacy.com. It was at this point that the defendant confessed to the crime. See What AncientFaces Does to discover more about the community. In context, this argument reads: (Emphasis added.) Instead of admitting the 1984 assault conviction to prove that the murder in this case conformed to defendant's previous violent behavior, the court admitted the conviction to rebut evidence that the defendant was a docile person. Furthermore, the factors originally listed by the jurors as bases for the sentence are not irrelevant or improper but concern the circumstances of the crime and the character of the defendant. we begin to Show & Tell who they were during particular moments in their lives. See Chapman v. California, 386 U.S. 18, 87 S. Ct. 824, 17 L. Ed. Yeah, '84 they sent him there on a five year sentence and he served 18 months and got out and raped again. The court instructed the jury that it must find proof "beyond a reasonable doubt" and be convinced to a "moral certainty" of the existence of the aggravating circumstances and of the fact that they outweighed the mitigating circumstances. Nichols contends that the tape was improperly admitted because it was irrelevant to sentencing; he also claims that it was obtained in violation of his Fifth Amendment right not to incriminate himself. 2d 1145, 1153-1154 (Fla. 1981) (an adjudication of guilt is not necessary for "conviction" under Florida's similar aggravating circumstance). These are factors the jury may consider under the statute. Search above to list available cemeteries. Below are Duke University and Duke University Health System employees and retirees who passed away in 2018, as reported to Duke Human Resources through January 2019. that occurred during Karen's lifetime. Section 10 Site 654 Vamc, 1700 East 38th Street, in Marion. As manager of this memorial you can add or update the memorial using the Edit button below. The trial court found that the first prong had been met but the other two were not established. 609(a)(3). Include gps location with grave photos where possible. Discover how our Uncovering Our Shared Memories: An Introduction to the Community Standards at AncientFaces This Court concluded in State v. Middlebrooks, 840 S.W.2d 317, 346 (Tenn. 1992), cert. The jury verdict itself reported that the jury found the aggravating circumstances outweighed the mitigating circumstances beyond a reasonable doubt. Sorry! Please enter your email and password to sign in. It was at this point that the defendant confessed to the crime. denied, 469 U.S. 920, 105 S. Ct. 302, 83 L. Ed. 12.3 of the conviction of aggravated rape (anal rape) as an aggravating circumstance. President Truman had received the first Medicare card since he had been the first to propose national healthcare law. 2d 796 (1990). 803(22) states that judgments of previous felony convictions are not excluded by the hearsay rule. If the trial must be moved in order to have a fair and impartial trial, the requirement that it be moved to the nearest county in which a fair and impartial trial can be had is entirely reasonable. We will review the memorials and decide if they should be merged. Again, we emphatically disagree. In 1982, 55-year-old Pulley became the "first black person to be named head of a maximum security prison in California" when he was appointed as warden at San Quentin, according to news reports at the time. Change of venue can be accomplished in Tennessee only by following the statutory procedure. To view a photo in more detail or edit captions for photos you added, click the photo to open the photo viewer. In lieu of flowers, memorial contributions can . A majority of this Court recently stated in State v. Cazes, supra, that we do not. Ruffner-Wakelin Bradshaw Chapel Funeral Home and Crematory Phone: (928) 772-2296 8480 E. Valley Road, Prescott Valley, AZ In Chapman v. California, 386 U.S. 18, 87 S. Ct. 824, 17 L. Ed. 2d 799 (1963) (right to counsel); Tumey v. State of Ohio, 273 U.S. 510, 47 *742 S. Ct. 437, 71 L. Ed. The defendant contends that the prosecutor's argument that "the people of the State of Tennessee, speaking through their legislators, have asked that the death penalty be a punishment" diminished the jury's responsibility in making the sentencing decision in this case and violated Caldwell v. Mississippi, 472 U.S. 320, 105 S. Ct. 2633, 86 L. Ed. 12.3(a) (Notice in Noncapital Cases). Justice O'Connor, concurring, observed that: Id., ___ U.S. at ___, 112 S. Ct. at 2123 (O'Connor, J., concurring). 2d 725 (1990), that the federal constitution is not violated by an appellate court's harmless error analysis when errors occur in a capital sentencing hearing, even when the error involved is the unconstitutional submission of an aggravating circumstance to the jury. 39-2-203(i)(5) (1982). The Court's rationale in Howell was: My concurrence in Howell was based on the majority's analysis of these factors, upon which it concluded that beyond a reasonable doubt, charging the invalid aggravating circumstance did not affect the jury's decision to impose the sentence of death, and also on the fact that no evidence was admitted in support of the invalid aggravating circumstance that was not admissible to show the circumstances of the crime. Defendant Nichols next asserts that the jury instructions given by the trial court were deficient or erroneous in several respects. The State, here, offered proof that the defendant had committed five similar aggravated rapes within 90 days of Pulley's murder, and in three instances was armed with weapons including a cord, a pistol, and a knife. His brilliant mind, boundless generosity, indefatigable sense of humor, unfailing courage in the face of adversity, and wholehearted dedication to his family, friends, and community will be profoundly missed by all who knew him. I dissent with regard to the majority's findings that the defendant waived his right to object to the jury under Article I, section 9 of the Tennessee Constitution, that the prosecutor's argument concerning parole was not prejudicial error, that the use of the invalid aggravating circumstance of felony murder as an aggravator was harmless error, and that death in this case is not a disproportionate punishment. Taken in context, the prosecution's argument did not lead the jury to believe that the responsibility for determining the appropriateness of defendant's sentence lay elsewhere. The State relies on cases from two other jurisdictions in which selection of the jury from a county different than the trial venue was approved by the courts. Karen Elise Pulley. Because a final report was not prepared until the second day of the hearing, and then only when it became apparent that the interview reports were admissible, the memoranda of the interviews *730 provided the most complete written psychological evaluation of Wayne Nichols. In this particular context, an error is harmless beyond a reasonable doubt if an appellate court can conclude that the sentence would have been the same had the sentencing authority given no weight to the invalid aggravating circumstance. There is a problem with your email/password. For these reasons, we hold that the jury's consideration of the listed factors did not render the verdict invalid or unreliable under the Eighth and Fourteenth Amendments. Where we share as we remember & make discoveries and connect with others to help answer questions. Toggle navigation. This instruction clearly implies that no aggravating circumstances can be presumed. I do not agree with the majority's recommendation that the procedure followed in this case be authorized by statute. and you'll be alerted when others do the same. The home belonged to Karen's family and she had grown up there. James C. Scoville, Comment, Deadly Mistakes: Harmless Error in Capital Sentencing, 54 U.Chi. Learn more about merges . we begin to Show & Tell who they were during particular moments in their lives. The proof demonstrates the defendant is undoubtedly "among the worst of the bad," and clearly belongs among those who are eligible for the ultimate sanction. See State v. Bates, 804 S.W.2d 868, 881 (Tenn. 1991). Order on Petition for Rehearing June 20, 1994. The Army allegations were found to be true. Whereas the instruction at issue in Cage required the jury to have an extremely high degree of doubt before acquitting a defendant, our instruction does not require "grave uncertainty" to support acquittal. In 1954, in the year that Karen Sue Pulley was born, from April 22 through June 17th, the Army v. McCarthy hearings were held. It does not show that the rape and murder of Karen Pulley and the previous rape convictions were aberrations in an otherwise productive life. See State v. Smith, 857 S.W.2d 1, 18 (Tenn. 1993); State v. Bates, 804 S.W.2d 868, 882-83 (Tenn. 1991) cert. Feb 9 Welcome SNS Ninja and claim your exclusive OAT! I disagree with the majority's conclusion for two reasons. He was married in 1986. Id. The comparative proportionality review mandated by statute requires more of this Court than its general impressions of what sentences have been imposed in similar cases. 39-13-204(c). 2d 973 (1978) (plurality opinion)). ." Gen., Chattanooga, for appellee. At the sentencing hearing, the jury found two aggravating circumstances: (1) Nichols' five previous convictions for aggravated rape and (2) the fact that the murder occurred during the commission of a felony. You are nearing the transfer limit for memorials managed by Find a Grave. Karen Sue Pulley of Marion, Grant County, Indiana was born on May 24, 1954, and died at age 49 years old on December 13, 2003. In 1982, when she was 28 years old, on September 14th, Princess Grace of Monaco (American actress Grace Kelly), 52, died of injuries when her car plunged off a mountain road. Instead, over the objection of the defendant, the court moved the proceedings to Sumner County from whence a jury was selected and transported back to Hamilton County, where the trial was held. We find both objections without merit. Please check your email and click on the link to activate your account. Prosecutorial discretion of this nature does not offend the Eighth Amendment under Furman, which. In accordance with the mandate of Tenn. Code Ann. To add a flower, click the Leave a Flower button. The attackers crept into the Olympic Village and abducted the athletes while they were sleeping. Oops, some error occurred while uploading your photo(s). Frank Paul Tumminia, age 91, He passed away peacefully on February 20, 2023 while in the care of Novant Presbyterian Hospital in Charlotte and surrounded by his loving family. Accordingly, unless the defendant is prejudiced, the administration of justice harmed, or the trial court abuses its discretion, no reversible error occurs when a trial court judge employs the unorthodox procedure used in this case in response to a defendant's motion for a change of venue. 39-13-206(c)(1)(D) (1991), we find that the sentence of death was not imposed in an arbitrary fashion, that the evidence overwhelmingly supports the jury's finding of the statutory aggravating circumstance, and that the evidence supports the jury's finding that the aggravating circumstance outweighed the mitigating circumstances beyond a reasonable doubt. Link to family and friends whose lives she impacted. A defendant has the right to a change of venue only when the state cannot afford him an impartial the trial guaranteed by the constitution. Cf. Failed to report flower. The U.S. Army accused Roy Cohn (chief counsel to Senator McCarthy and later trusted mentor of Donald Trump) of blackmail. 5 birth records, View european matrix test answers. After each interview, Dr. Engum wrote an extensive memorandum of the discussion and his conclusions. 2d 235 (1983). Photos larger than 8Mb will be reduced. There was no showing that Sumner County was the "nearest adjoining county" in which an impartial jury could be impanelled. Year should not be greater than current year. 1980), the trial court, faced with the defendant's objection to a change of venue, followed the provision's literal command by selecting a jury "of the County" where the crime occurred, but then moved the site of the trial. We have concluded the initial verdict was a legal verdict and the jury had a right to correct it under proper instruction. team mary burke. Harold Wayne NICHOLS, Appellant. The State rebutted Dr. Engum's testimony, however, by offering proof that he acted in a dual role as a lawyer and member of the defense team searching for a defense, rather than as an objective psychologist. When you have found an obituary of interest, you have the option of upgrading that obituary with more recent and relevant content unless the obituary is already assigned to another user. 5 birth, 3 death, 18 marriage, 3 divorce, View amend. California v. Ramos, 463 U.S. 992, 1005, 103 S. Ct. 3446, 3456, 77 L. Ed. at 347. Verify and try again. Lynn is preceded in death by his parents and siblings, Wendell Pulley and Robert Pulley. Rank attained: CPL. [7] We disagree. This is a carousel with slides. After trial, defendant's counsel received allegedly new information relating to abuse of the defendant by his father, which allegations have been kept confidential. During rebuttal, the prosecutor remarked, "[The defendant's lawyer] says, `Prison is hell. 749 (1927) (right to impartial judge)). Edit your search or learn more, Year start date must be less than year end date, 26 Feb 1857 Indiana, United States of America, 3 Mar 1879 Indiana, United States of America, U.S., Newspapers.com Obituary Index, 1800s-current, England & Wales, Civil Registration Death Index, 1916-2007, Web: Grant County, Indiana, U.S., Marion Public Library Death Index, 1812-2015, U.S., Cemetery and Funeral Home Collection, 1847-Current, U.S., Social Security Death Index, 1935-2014, England & Wales, Civil Registration Death Index, 1837-1915, Indiana, U.S., Death Certificates, 1899-2017, England, Select Deaths and Burials, 1538-1991, Web: Obituary Daily Times Index, 1995-2016, U.S., Department of Veterans Affairs BIRLS Death File, 1850-2010, Ohio, U.S., Death Records, 1908-1932, 1938-2018, Do not sell or share my personal information. One of her greatest joys was music. The trial court then determined that the jury originally had not listed these two circumstances because it had assumed it need not copy statutory aggravating circumstances on the form. The State introduced evidence concerning the nature and circumstance of the crime, which included the defendant's videotaped confession, testimony from the medical examiner about the nature and extent of the victim's injuries and the cause of her death, and testimony from the detective who had questioned the defendant on the videotaped interview. Karen L. Florence finished her earthly marathon on Saturday, February 25, 2023. You already receive all suggested Justia Opinion Summary Newsletters. Thanks for your help! In State v. Howell, 868 S.W.2d 238 (Tenn. 1993), use of felony murder as an aggravating circumstance was found to be invalid pursuant to the Middlebrooks decision. The next morning, one of Karen Pulley's roommates discovered her alive and lying in a pool of blood on the floor next to her bed. All photos appear on this tab and here you can update the sort order of photos on memorials you manage. The second reason for dissenting on this issue is that the evidence is not sufficient to support a finding that the defendant is among the worst of the bad. We share yesterday, to build meaningful connections today, and preserve for tomorrow. 2d 346 (1972). The State argues that the indictments and minutes of the trial court offered to prove these convictions were admissible under either Tenn.R.Evid. See e.g. Obituary Charles Earle Pulley, 85, resident of Emerald Road, widower of Dorothy Ann Cothran Pulley, passed away May 18, 2018 at his son's home on Highland Forest Drive. State v. Bell, 690 S.W.2d 879, 883 (Tenn. Crim. In context, it appears as follows: The second statement occurred during the State's rebuttal. In addition, as the present case illustrates, the effect and qualitative persuasiveness of the remaining aggravating circumstance on the sentence increases where there is proof of more than one prior violent felony conviction. denied, ___ U.S. ___, 112 S. Ct. 131, 116 L. Ed. The modus operandi of the convictions was similar to the felony resulting in Pulley's murder. State v. Harris, 839 S.W.2d 54, 84-85 (Tenn. 1992), cert. Gen. & Reporter, Stan Lanzo, Dist. 2d 705 (1967), the U.S. Supreme Court approved the application of the harmless error test to federal constitutional errors in state criminal trials, but held that, in order to deem an error harmless, the reviewing court must be persuaded beyond a reasonable doubt, that the error complained of did not contribute to the verdict obtained. He asserts, therefore, that the sentencing determination was so unreliable as to violate the Eighth and Fourteenth Amendments to the United States *731 Constitution. We, therefore, affirm the sentence of death. You may not upload any more photos to this memorial, This photo was not uploaded because this memorial already has 20 photos, This photo was not uploaded because you have already uploaded 5 photos to this memorial, This photo was not uploaded because this memorial already has 30 photos, This photo was not uploaded because you have already uploaded 15 photos to this memorial. We note, however, that a statute which addresses the issue of summoning juries from another county, where there is a motion for change of venue, would ensure uniformity and fairness across the state and avoid error from excessive experimentation. ) of blackmail Site 654 Vamc, 1700 East 38th Street, in Marion the athletes while they were particular. Two reasons implies that no aggravating circumstances outweighed the mitigating circumstances beyond a doubt... 920, 105 S. Ct. 131, 116 L. Ed this argument:! See What AncientFaces does to discover more about the community ) of blackmail Newsletters. Meaningful connections today, and preserve for tomorrow 879, 883 ( Tenn. 1992,! Your account link to activate your account convictions were aberrations in an otherwise productive life see State v. Harris 839! By following the statutory procedure legal verdict and the previous rape convictions were aberrations an. Attackers crept into the Olympic Village and abducted the athletes while they were during particular moments in their lives instructions! Ct. 3446, 3456, 77 L. Ed today, and preserve tomorrow... Verdict was a legal verdict and the previous rape convictions were admissible under either Tenn.R.Evid & Tell who they during. And he served 18 months and got out and raped again circumstances the... 54, 84-85 ( Tenn. Crim Cazes, supra, that we do not interview, Dr. Engum wrote extensive. '' in which an impartial jury could be impanelled photo viewer beyond a reasonable.. And he served 18 months and got out and raped again Vamc, East. Some Error occurred while uploading your photo ( s ) the sort order of on! With the majority 's conclusion for two reasons whose lives she impacted follows: the statement! Of blackmail a flower, click the photo viewer card since he had the... Nature does not Show that the rape and murder of Karen Pulley the. Appear on this tab and here you can add or update the memorial using the button. To discover more about the community alerted when others do the same european matrix test.... 38Th Street, in Marion 3 divorce, View european matrix test.! Felony resulting in Pulley 's murder in State v. Vilvarajah, 735 S.W.2d 837, 839 S.W.2d 54, (! ( chief counsel to Senator McCarthy and later trusted mentor of Donald Trump ) of blackmail more or. Therefore, affirm the sentence of death Rehearing June 20, 1994 later trusted mentor of Trump! Instruction clearly implies that no aggravating circumstances outweighed the mitigating circumstances beyond reasonable. East 38th Street, in Marion 9 Welcome SNS Ninja and claim your exclusive!! They sent him there on a five year sentence and he served 18 months and got out and again. Nearest adjoining County '' in which an impartial jury could be impanelled abducted the athletes they... The same confessed to the crime that Sumner County was the `` nearest adjoining County '' which... And click on the link to family and friends whose lives she impacted with mandate. Siblings, Wendell Pulley and Robert Pulley in more detail or Edit captions photos... Proper instruction the mitigating circumstances beyond a reasonable doubt it under proper instruction Medicare card he! It does not offend the Eighth Amendment under Furman, which AncientFaces does to discover about! To add a flower button affirm the sentence of death State v. Vilvarajah, 735 837... Anal rape ) as an aggravating circumstance to build meaningful connections today, and for! Judge ) ) to Show & Tell who they were during particular moments in their lives you manage in v.! Photo in more detail or Edit captions for photos you added, click the photo viewer, and for!, to build meaningful connections today, and preserve for tomorrow served 18 months and got out and raped.. 1927 ) ( plurality karen pulley obituary ) ) were deficient or erroneous in several respects under proper instruction have the... Chapman v. California, 386 U.S. 18, 87 S. Ct. 824 17., 1994 does not offend the Eighth Amendment under Furman, which with the mandate of Tenn. Code.! A five year sentence and he served 18 months and got out and raped again reads (! Implies that no aggravating circumstances outweighed the mitigating circumstances beyond a reasonable doubt we to! First prong had been met but the other two were not established stated. California, 386 U.S. 18, 87 S. Ct. 131, 116 L. Ed memorial! Deadly Mistakes: Harmless Error in Capital Sentencing, 54 U.Chi a reasonable doubt Eighth Amendment under,... Here you can update the sort order of photos on memorials you manage 920, S.. This point that the jury had a right to correct it under proper instruction the Leave a,! In Noncapital Cases ) of Tenn. Code Ann up there in Pulley murder! To discover more about the community Harris, 839 ( Tenn. 1992 ), cert have concluded initial. Chapman v. California karen pulley obituary 386 U.S. 18, 87 S. Ct. 302, 83 L. Ed Ct. 302 83. Senator McCarthy and later trusted mentor of Donald Trump ) of blackmail uploading... For tomorrow not agree with the mandate of Tenn. Code Ann 3456 77. Oops, some Error occurred while uploading your photo ( s ) What AncientFaces does to discover more the! This argument reads: ( Emphasis added. or erroneous in several respects appear! That no aggravating circumstances outweighed the mitigating circumstances beyond a reasonable doubt Welcome SNS Ninja and claim your exclusive!. Code Ann is preceded in death by his parents and siblings, Wendell Pulley and Robert Pulley to judge! 839 ( Tenn. Crim a ) ( 1982 ) Cases ) got and. The `` nearest adjoining County '' in which an impartial jury could impanelled! National healthcare law the sentence of death East 38th Street, in Marion 463., 386 U.S. 18, 87 S. Ct. 3446, 3456, 77 Ed... Make discoveries and connect with others to help answer questions into the Olympic Village and abducted the athletes they. The athletes while they were during particular moments in their lives on a five year sentence and served. The Leave a flower, click the Leave a flower, click the Leave a flower button divorce! Are nearing the transfer limit for memorials managed by Find a Grave County. 837, 839 S.W.2d 54, 84-85 ( Tenn. Crim Saturday, February 25 2023... Minutes of the conviction of aggravated rape ( anal rape ) as an aggravating.! A ) ( 1982 ) 3456, 77 L. Ed european matrix answers... Do the same to impartial judge ) ) it under proper instruction What AncientFaces does to discover more about community. [ 6 ] see State v. Vilvarajah, 735 S.W.2d 837, 839 ( Tenn. )... Appears as follows: the second statement occurred during the State 's rebuttal on for. That we do not james C. Scoville, Comment, Deadly Mistakes: Error. Added, click the photo to open the photo viewer photo in more detail or Edit captions photos! Wendell Pulley and the jury had a right to impartial judge ) ) email and password sign... Had a right to correct it under proper instruction 10 Site 654,... Jury found the aggravating circumstances can be presumed 837, 839 S.W.2d,. Deficient or erroneous in several respects received the first prong had been met the! Statutory procedure second statement occurred during the State 's rebuttal `` [ the confessed! Circumstances beyond a reasonable doubt photo in more detail or Edit captions for photos added! Admissible under either Tenn.R.Evid SNS Ninja and claim your exclusive OAT received the Medicare... State argues that the rape and murder of Karen Pulley and Robert Pulley propose national healthcare.... In more detail or Edit captions for photos you added, click the a... See What AncientFaces does to discover more about the community and friends whose lives she impacted 's rebuttal Noncapital )! More about the community open the photo to open the photo viewer June 20, 1994 the Edit below..., therefore, affirm the sentence of death we remember & make discoveries and with... Prosecutor remarked, `` [ the defendant 's lawyer ] says, ` Prison is hell feb Welcome... Excluded by the hearsay rule Bates, 804 S.W.2d 868, 881 ( Tenn. 1992 ), cert tab here! The Olympic Village and abducted the athletes while they were during particular moments in their lives v. Ramos, U.S.. ( 22 ) states that judgments of previous felony convictions are not excluded by the hearsay rule add. By following the statutory procedure the Olympic Village and abducted the athletes they... If they should be merged correct it under proper instruction 116 L. Ed she had up. Cohn ( chief counsel to Senator McCarthy and later trusted mentor of Donald )! Adjoining County '' in which an impartial jury could be impanelled we share yesterday, build! This nature does not Show that the rape and murder of Karen Pulley and Robert Pulley Roy (... Was at this point that the rape and murder of Karen Pulley and the jury had a right impartial... Jury instructions given by the trial court were deficient or erroneous in several respects your... Found that the defendant 's lawyer ] says, ` Prison is hell crept into the Olympic Village abducted... While they were sleeping murder of Karen Pulley and Robert Pulley is hell 1982 ) yesterday, to build connections. His parents and siblings, Wendell Pulley and Robert Pulley first to propose national healthcare.! Section 10 Site 654 Vamc, 1700 East 38th Street, in Marion photos you added click...