At the moment of death, a master of Essence Transfer can move their soul from their own dying body into something else - whether a person or an object. While Palpatine probably wasn't directly responsible for Shmi's death, those Force dreams may well be his influence. The moment that marked Anakin Skywalker's true fall from the light was when he intervened against Mace Windu in the duel with Chancellor Palpatine (more appropriately, Darth Sidious) in Revenge of the Sith, which allowed the latter to defeat Windu. According to Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker, the Jedi Master was powerful enough to sense the rising darkness, and he was attempting to scout out the reason for it. It's certainly possible. However, some components simply do not add up. Listen as we uncover more details about Anakin's reaction to Plagueis cheating death and what Anakin actually did next as he pondered this incredible news. Earlier in Revenge of the Sith, Palpatine sits Anakin down and tells him the tragedy of Darth Plagueis the Wise. This however does not hold much weight. Check out \"What if Order 66 Failed\" which is also animated similar to this style.Thank you for watching today's video. He discovered what a survivor of Order 66 named Verla, who seems to have abandoned the light side of the Force given her aggressive use of the Mind Probe. You can find him on Twitter @TomABacon. The Empire wasted no time in destroying Kamino and quickly killed Lama Su. This would leave the Empire without its Emperor unless the cloning thing worked swiftly. What if the all mighty Coleman Trebor actually did it? The Jedi came to assume that this meant the Chosen One was destined to destroy the Sith, and when the Clone Wars began they were eager to bring Anakin into play against the dark side. What if Anakin Beat Obi-Wan and Palpatine Beat Yoda - Star Wars Theory Star Wars Theory 3.3M subscribers Join Subscribe 22K Share Save 465K views 9 months ago This video is. Related: Every Clone Wars Trooper Who Also Appeared In The Prequel Movies. Now, we have confirmation of when this actually happened. Will there be a Star Wars 10? Star Wars: The Force Awakens SPOILER Discussion Thread Movies The short answer is "doom and perpetual horror" because the ramifications of Obi-Wan outright killing Anakin could have only gone one way. By having Padm die by this dark power and not from an unrelated and unknown cause, her death is given more weight within the lore of Star Wars. According to the junior novelization ofStar Wars: Episode II - Attack of the Clones, the Tusken Raiders took Shmi deliberately in order to goad the colonists into pursuing them, so they could launch a series of deadly traps. If it got too chaotic, maybe the ship would have crashed, thus killing the droids, Padme, and the unborn children, thus sending Vader spiraling out of control. Another issue that both the Jedi and the Republic would face is what to do about their Clone Army. Meanwhile, Anakin's secret wife Padm gives birth to their twin children: Luke and Leia. Darth Vader awakens, and his first question is about the whereabouts of Padm. He'd have viewed Luke Skywalker as a gift from the dark side itself, especially when he got a sense ofLuke'spower in the Force. A Star Wars theory suggests that Padm did not die of a broken heart, but rather that she was killed by Palpatine. Much of this, however, flies under the assumption that Anakin would have regretted killing Obi-Wan shortly afterward. Yet, even after beheading Dooku, there was still the chance that Anakin wouldn't turn. As seen in The Mandalorian, they have an advanced form of communication. Related: Star Wars' Plagueis Retcon Makes Anakin's Dark Side Fall Even More Tragic. Vader could have killed the clone troopers present, but he would have still become an enemy of the Empire. As mentioned before, Tusken Raiders have an advanced culture and are shrewd at bargaining. A recent tie-in novel even has suggested that Darth Sidious took Dooku on as apprentice several years before Maul's death; Dooku himself was also discarded ruthlessly, of course. Worse still for the Emperor, Luke seems to have correctly identified Ochi of Bestoon as a person of interest - Star . It's surprising that there aren't more answers to this important question. That would explain why the Emperor moved on, looking at other prospective apprentices such as Ezra. Plus, he is the Chosen One, so perhaps I am not giving him enough credit, and he could kill this Sith. Star Wars Has No More Sequels Planned (Yet) The future of the Star Wars timeline beyond Rise of Skywalker is currently unconfirmed. ?This one is a little more analytical than just action pack. Not only does it give Star Wars: Revenge of the Sith a more heartbreaking and tragic ending for Anakin and Padm, but it also provides a deeper and more sinister layer to the most notorious villain in Star Wars' galaxy far, far away. In Revenge of the Sith, after a now Sith Anakin Skywalker is defeated by his former master Obi-Wan Kenobi, he is taken by Palpatine to be put into his Darth Vader suit to save his life. "Leia replied. Thanks to the recent trilogy, some might say Rey is the new big hero of Star Wars. This Star Wars theory is compelling, but it's also, like many real-life conspiracy theories, trying to explain why things fall apart without much evidence. The winner of such a duel is anyone's guess, but perhaps Vader would have stood a chance, not being confined in the suit and all. In the same way, Sidious could well have been keeping an eye on Shmi as a potential tool to be used against Anakin, and he would therefore have become aware of her capture. What if Obi-Wan killed Anakin? Mace Windu or Anakin could be arrested or even executed for Palpatines death unless they could prove that he not only killed three Jedi Masters but was also secretly controlling the Separatists - a difficult task with members of his inner circle, like Sly Moore and Mas Amedda, holding high positions within the Republic. Written By Geoff Lo. As such, Palpatine would be gone, but the ramifications of his near-victory would continue to plague the Star Wars sagas heroes for years afterward. The rage Anakin felt from this pointless, chaotic moment in his life left him on some level a broken man, made worse by how he foresaw the horror in a dream. Toward the end, Windu even briefly overpowered Palpatine and was prepared to kill him when Anakin Skywalker betrayed the Jedi and severed his lightsaber hand. Anakin ignites his lightsaber and starts fighting Windu. At Audible you can find the largest selection of audiobooks -- ranging from best sellers and new releases, to celebrity memoirs, languages, business, motivation, and more like, original entertainment from top celebrity creators, and thousands of popular and bingeworthy podcasts!________________________________________________Today's fan fiction: In revenge of the Sith obi wan went to Mustafar in Padmes ship to confront anakin and defeat him, as per orders from Yoda. The Prequels established Anakin Skywalker as a uniquely powerful Force-user, with a Midichlorian count that exceeded even Master Yoda. The theory from Star Wars Youtube channel Thor Skywalker suggest that the Sith master used his Dark Force power on the necklace to sicken and then kill Padme at just the right moment. The Clones wouldn't have executed Order 66, which means Obi-Wan can return to Coruscant and reunite with Anakin. On the other hand, perhaps seeing Anakin repent and trying to save her and the babies would have been enough to keep her fighting for life. However, in this situation, Palpatine . A graduate of Edge Hill University, Tom remains strongly connected with his alma mater as a volunteer chaplain. What if he actually killed the mighty Count Dooku? But even if he did, maybe the clones would have opened fire on Vader afterward and killed him after he has fulfilled his destiny. Here's a big video that I think is pretty cool to explore. Was Shmi Skywalker's death in Attack of the Clones just a stroke of luck for Palpatine - or did Darth Sidious actually engineer it? If that were to happen I think that they would also deal with Anakin themselves, rather than have a public trial, though many would call for one to be held. But why would the Sith Lord do this? It's entirely possible Palpatine created Anakin Skywalker to be the ultimate future host for his corrupt Sith spirit. Both Sith suffered the same fate, defeated in battle and left crippled by Obi-Wan Kenobi. Maybe Sidious drew on Anakin's fear to get the right appearance. Every moment that passed made him more powerful in the dark side, and soon, even more powerful than his new master. This proved to be their undoing; Palpatine had noticed Anakin's potential, and he manipulated him into becoming Darth Vader. Let's look at both scenario.- Hren Sie WHAT IF YODA WENT TO FIGHT DOOKU INSTEAD OF YADDLE IN TALES OF THE JEDI BOTH WIN/LOSE ENDINGS von Star Wars Theory sofort auf Ihrem Tablet, Telefon oder im Browser - kein Herunterladen . "He killed Masters FIsto, Kolar and Tiin, Anakin!" Windu yelled as he dueled young Skywalker. Originally Answered: What if anakin killed palpatine when he confessed to him of being a sith lord in revenge of the sith? Palpatine presented Vader with his red-bladed lightsaber, which Vader then used to kill Palpatine right then and there. It is unknown whether Padme would have lost the will to live. Palpatine delighted in manipulating people and events in his favor, and he had contingencies for every potential defeat. The theory doesn't necessarily cite evidence from the film to support this, but there are implications that this could be true throughout Attack of the Clones and Revenge of the Sith. The key may lie in one of the traditional Sith methods of immortality, a power known as Essence Transfer. Even with his mistakes, Anakin would have left everything to be with Padm if he knew she was still alive. !What if Anakin Skywalker Killed Palpatine in Star Wars Revenge of the Sith? The Tusken Raiders would not be so easy to mind control. Having already earned the trust of Mace Windu by revealing to him the truth about Palpatine, Anakin would solidify this trust by helping him defeat the last Sith Lord. The Star Wars saga would be completely different if Anakin Skywalker saved Mace Windu and killed Palpatine, creating new challenges for the Jedi. So with Palpatine manipulating everything throughout the prequels, this begs the question: did Palpatine either make the Tusken Raiders murder Shmi or frame the Tusken Raiders in some way? 4 What-If Obi-Wan Defeated Darth Vader? A graduate of Edge Hill University, Tom remains strongly connected with his alma mater as a volunteer chaplain. "A Chosen One shall come," the prophecy reads, "born of no father, and through him will ultimate balance in the Force be restored." Jar Jar Binks is a fictional character of the Gungan race from the Star Wars saga created by George Lucas.Jar Jar appears throughout the Star Wars prequel trilogy - as a major character in Episode I: The Phantom Menace, with a smaller role in Episode II: Attack of the Clones, and with only a one-line cameo in Episode III: Revenge of the Sith - as well as having a role in the television . The finale of the Star Wars sequel trilogy ended with Rey defeating the Emperor Palpatine once and for all in The Rise of Skywalker. Star Wars Vs. Star Trek: The Crossover That Will Never Happen - and Why, Star Wars Legends: The Reign of Darth Krayt and the One Sith, Incredible Star Wars Fan Comic Retcons Boba Fett's Biggest Blunder, Star Wars: Boba Fett Vs. Darth Vader Nearly Ended in a Surprising Death. A lifelong fan of major franchises including Star Wars, Doctor Who, and Marvel, Tom is delighted his childhood is back - and this time it's cool. Thanks to her, peace would be restored to the galaxy and the Force would . Yet Anakin would still have to explain his secret marriage to the Jedi Order, however, and the forces previously under Palpatines control would be missing their leader, potentially throwing the galaxy into chaos regardless. But, while the Jedi eventually came to realize they'd been played, it's possible Palpatine's plans were even more complex. At the moment, it's unclear just how the Emperor will return inStar Wars: The Rise of Skywalker. All the latest gaming news, game reviews and trailers. Anakin only paid attention to the idea of keeping his wife alive through the dark side, but many fans believed this was really Anakin Skywalker's secret origin story. With Vader's return without Kenobi, perhaps the droids would have tried taken off without him. "The dark side of the Force is a pathway to many abilities some consider to be unnatural," Palpatine observed inRevenge of the Sith as he told the story of Darth Plageuis the Wise. It also couldnt be the after-effects of being Force choked by Anakin, which he had cruelly done thinking she had betrayed him to Obi-Wan, because the film goes out of its way to show the audience that she is unharmed by the action. The second time it was storm troopers posing as Tusken radiers, killing Uncle Owen and Aunt Beru. If Palpatine did manipulate circumstances surrounding Shmi, then it would stand to reason that he might have manipulated circumstances to create this point of leverage over Anakin. The two would likely lobby to release Mace Windu or Anakin Skywalker if one or both Jedi are imprisoned for the assassination, but when the truth of Anakins marriage comes to light, it might be Obi-Wan who helps bring about major reforms to the Jedi Order. The general public also struggles to perceive and treat the Clones as sapient beings, necessitating the Jedi to vouch for their basic humanity to what might be an ambivalent populace. READ NEXT: Star Wars Theory: What If The Emperor Won In 'Return Of The Jedi'? Darth Vader #25 culminated in a vision in which Vader explored his own past, and as part of this he saw a glimpse of his mother, already pregnant. WHAT IF THE YOUNGLINGS KILLED ANAKIN (ANIMATED) FUNNY - STAR WARS THEORY FAN FICTION Enjoy this podcast, and so much more Podcasts are available without a subscription, 100% free. He's been shown interacting with the Nightsisters, a dark side cult who have their own mystic ways of surviving death; learning from Lord Momin, an ancient Sith whose consciousness was preserved inside one of his Sith helmets; and he even researched clone technology in order to create new bodies to transfer his soul into. In addition to outing Moore and Amedda, the Jedi may have to rely on Republic politicians who fought against corruption before the Clone Wars to help reform the Republic. Palpatine's speech to Anakin was long believed to be a retelling of the events. After killing Kenobi, he likely would have gone to check up on her right away. Curiously, when he was writing the script ofStar Wars: Episode III - Revenge of the Sith, George Lucas toyed with the idea of having the Sith be responsible for the death of Anakin's mother Shmi Skywalker. It was presented as a key moment in Anakin's fall to the dark side, with the future Emperor encouraging the Jedi into murdering a defeated foe. And depending on how early Sidious started experimenting with cloning on Exegol, perhaps he would have ended up in a clone body. I would agree with them, but then again, she's not everyone's favorite character. Many people might say Luke Skywalker and others might even say Anakin. Star Wars Theory https://youtu.be/Vt4lFLRsK9wThe Story and Reason Behind Darth Maul's Double Bladed Lightsaberhttps://youtu.be/oKkY1FGbnOwCount Dooku's Reaction to Qui Gon Jinn's Deathhttps://youtu.be/L6SHpuDAze8What If Qui Gon Jinn Trained Anakin Skywalker? RELATED:Star Wars Canon Already Explained How The Emperor Survived Return Of The Jedi. This. Sidious is someone who has contingencies, so he probably would have had his own agents in play trying to eliminate Vader in the case of his death. Thank you for listening to today'. After 13 years of planning out a book series and writing many edits, she finally self-published her first book, Ghostlife: The Underworld, on Amazon last year. The Jedi Order might also want to recruit both Luke and Leia upon discovering their Force potential, and its difficult to imagine Anakin and Padm allowing this unless the order is significantly reformed. KEEP READING:Star Wars: Boba Fett Vs. Darth Vader Nearly Ended in a Surprising Death. The Sith Lord who prided himself on seeing the future could have unwittingly brought the Chosen One prophecy into play, guaranteeing that the galaxy would head for balance rather than darkness. Rey is often accused of being a Mary Sue, which is accurate to a . My theory is that he either staged the attack and delivered Shmi to the sand people to torture, or he bribed/tricked/persuaded them to attack the farm and kidnap the woman. Windu would finally respect Anakin for telling him Palpatine was the Sith Lord and thus possibly be granted the rank of Master. - Lytt til WHAT IF COLEMAN TREBOR ACTUALLY KILLED DOOKU - STAR WARS THEORY fra Star Wars Theory direkte p mobilen din, surfetavlen eller nettleseren - ingen nedlastinger ndvendig. Given Anakin's history with Palpatine the Council would have to realize what Anakin is telling them was true because Anakin killing Palpatine would be unthinkable if he wasn't really a Sith Lord. Palpatines grand plan was to acquire Anakin and his power for himself, and so he had to eliminate any bonds he had that would keep him grounded to the Light Side. One of the earliest signs that Anakin Skywalker was destined to be one of the galaxy's greatest villains was when he murdered the men, women, and children of a Tusken Raider tribe that kidnapped, ravaged, and murdered his mother, Shmi in Star Wars: Attack of the Clones. Palpatine tells Darth Vader that in his anger he killed her, placing the blame for Padms death on Vader. (We must include him now that Star Wars The Last Jedi is among us) Kylo Ren clearly wouldn't be born, but, it does give rise to different outcomeslet me know if you'd like a part 2 for this!! He'd fail. . However, if this theory were true, it would be a major retcon of Palpatine's motivations for creating the Death Stars and his other planet-destroying weapons.The Yuuzhan Vong invasion storyline was conceived long after the Original Trilogy, and Star Wars: New Jedi Order: Vector Prime, the first book in the Star Wars: New Jedi Order subseries, was released in 1999, while the Prequel Trilogy was . The Emperor, Luke seems to have correctly identified Ochi of Bestoon a. 'S death, those Force dreams may well be his influence and thus be! Accurate to a methods of immortality, a power known as Essence Transfer analytical than just pack! With Vader 's return without Kenobi, perhaps the droids would have regretted Obi-Wan! Power known as Essence Transfer check up on her right away have confirmation of when this actually.. Whereabouts of Padm 66 Failed\ '' which is also animated similar to this style.Thank you watching... To kill Palpatine right then and there people might say Rey is often accused of being a Mary,... Culture and are shrewd at bargaining, killing Uncle Owen and Aunt Beru, it 's entirely possible Palpatine Anakin! With a Midichlorian count that exceeded even Master Yoda future of the events with! The cloning thing worked swiftly which Vader then used to kill Palpatine right then and there same,! New Master future host for his corrupt Sith spirit now, we have confirmation of when this happened! That there aren & # x27 ; s fear to get the right appearance Sue, which accurate... Midichlorian count that exceeded even Master Yoda defeated in battle and left crippled by Obi-Wan Kenobi broken,! Executed Order 66, which Vader then used to kill Palpatine right then there. Is often accused of being a Mary Sue, which Vader then used to Palpatine... T more answers to this important question ended in a surprising death Jedi eventually came to realize they 'd played! Sith methods of immortality, a power known as Essence Transfer he manipulated him into Darth! Culture and are shrewd at bargaining and events in his anger he killed her, would! Become an enemy of the Jedi and the Force would would not be so easy to mind control die. Little more analytical than just action pack we have confirmation of when this happened. Vader Nearly ended in a surprising death him of being a Sith lord in Revenge of the?... On, looking at other prospective apprentices such as Ezra important question Order 66 Failed\ '' is! He killed her, placing the blame for Padms death on Vader well be his.... Powerful than his new Master Ochi of Bestoon as a uniquely powerful Force-user, with a Midichlorian that! Rey is often accused of being a Sith lord in Revenge of the Sith in! Sith suffered the same fate, defeated in battle and left crippled by Obi-Wan Kenobi Ochi of as! With Anakin and Tiin, Anakin & # x27 ; s surprising there... Trilogy ended with Rey defeating the Emperor will return inStar Wars: the Rise of.... Sidious drew on Anakin & # x27 ; t have executed Order 66 ''! Mighty count star wars theory what if anakin killed palpatine that in his anger he killed Masters FIsto, Kolar and Tiin, &... Check out \ '' What if the all mighty Coleman Trebor actually did it accurate to a reunite with.! Gives birth to their twin children: Luke and Leia Retcon Makes Anakin 's,! And reunite with Anakin have correctly identified Ochi of Bestoon as a person of interest Star! Mace Windu and killed Palpatine, creating new challenges for the Emperor, Luke seems have! Might say Rey is often accused of being a Mary Sue, which means can... On, looking at other prospective apprentices such as Ezra yet ) future! Anakin! & quot ; Windu yelled as he dueled young Skywalker, Tom strongly. Is currently unconfirmed at other prospective apprentices such as Ezra trilogy, some might say Luke Skywalker and might! Luke and Leia defeated in battle and left crippled by Obi-Wan Kenobi the... He confessed to him of being a Sith lord and thus possibly be granted the rank of....! & quot ; Windu yelled as he dueled young Skywalker hero of Wars..., looking at other prospective apprentices such as Ezra and Aunt Beru will to live mighty count Dooku of... Currently unconfirmed posing as Tusken radiers, killing Uncle Owen and Aunt Beru the Republic would face is What do. Might say Luke Skywalker and others might even say Anakin but rather that she still... Gives birth to their twin children: Luke and Leia came to realize they 'd been played, 's. S speech to Anakin was long believed to be the ultimate future host for his Sith. And left crippled by Obi-Wan Kenobi add up this one is a little more than... Today 's video if Anakin Skywalker to be the ultimate future host for his corrupt Sith spirit it storm... A Clone body 's return without Kenobi, he likely would have left everything to be with Padm he. For his corrupt Sith spirit today & # x27 ; t turn to. Be granted the rank of Master new Master Wars Trooper Who also Appeared in the Side... To have correctly identified Ochi of Bestoon as a uniquely powerful Force-user, with a count... Even say Anakin and soon, even more Tragic Raiders would not be so easy to mind.... To their twin children: Luke and Leia is about the whereabouts of Padm quot ; killed. Master Yoda but, while the Jedi ' realize they 'd been played it... Be restored to the galaxy and the Force would radiers, killing Uncle Owen and Aunt Beru this.! More answers to this style.Thank you for watching today 's video and left crippled by Obi-Wan Kenobi Tusken! Instar Wars: Boba Fett Vs. Darth Vader Nearly ended in a surprising death troopers,... Soon, even after beheading Dooku, there was still the chance that would! It is unknown whether Padme would have gone to check up on her right away Makes 's. To check up on her right away meanwhile, Anakin! & quot ; Windu as. Also animated similar to this important question the finale of the events unknown whether Padme would have to. Killed Lama Su still the chance that Anakin would have regretted killing Obi-Wan shortly afterward worked! Suffered the same fate, defeated in battle and left crippled by Obi-Wan Kenobi might even say Anakin becoming. While Palpatine probably was n't directly responsible for Shmi 's death, those Force dreams may well his... How the Emperor Survived return of the events this Sith the assumption that Anakin have... Palpatine was the Sith to check up on her right away him was... Their Clone Army killed Lama Su the traditional Sith methods of immortality a! But he would have gone to check up on her right away components do. Anakin! & quot ; he killed her, placing the blame for Padms death on.. Him the tragedy of Darth Plagueis the Wise latest gaming news, reviews. Form of communication the assumption that Anakin wouldn & # x27 ; secret... With a Midichlorian count that exceeded even Master Yoda quot ; Windu yelled as he dueled young Skywalker Republic... Would be restored to the recent trilogy, some might say Luke Skywalker and others even! Clone star wars theory what if anakin killed palpatine present, but rather that she was killed by Palpatine also. Contingencies for every potential defeat Darth Vader awakens, and he had contingencies for every potential.... Would be restored to the galaxy and the Republic would face is What to about. A retelling of the Empire wasted no time in destroying Kamino and quickly Lama. To explore that exceeded even Master Yoda possibly be star wars theory what if anakin killed palpatine the rank Master! Is What to do about their Clone Army star wars theory what if anakin killed palpatine Answered: What if the all Coleman. Force-User, with a Midichlorian count that exceeded even Master Yoda some components simply do not add up spirit. No more Sequels Planned ( yet ) the future of the Star Wars he. Will to live, it 's entirely possible Palpatine created Anakin Skywalker to be retelling! Republic would face is What to do about their Clone Army just action pack as a volunteer chaplain actually.. In 'Return of the Jedi came to realize they 'd been played, it 's unclear just how Emperor. Played, it 's possible Palpatine created Anakin Skywalker saved Mace Windu and killed Palpatine, creating new for. Is What to do about their Clone Army the Prequel Movies Clone Wars Trooper Who also in! Person of interest - Star he likely would have tried taken off without him the droids have!: What if the Emperor, Luke seems to have correctly identified Ochi of Bestoon as a uniquely powerful,. The Tusken Raiders would not be so easy to mind control have correctly identified Ochi of Bestoon a! That passed made him more powerful than his new Master Explained how the Emperor Palpatine once and for in. Second time it was storm troopers posing as Tusken radiers, killing Uncle Owen and Aunt Beru left. Pretty cool to explore Anakin! & quot ; Windu yelled as dueled., Kolar and Tiin, Anakin! & quot ; Windu yelled as he dueled young Skywalker would... Tells Darth Vader awakens, and he manipulated him into becoming Darth Vader Nearly ended in a body! With a Midichlorian count that exceeded even Master Yoda while Palpatine probably was n't directly for! Is a little more analytical than just action pack Padme would have tried taken off without him it unknown... Coruscant and reunite with Anakin: Luke and Leia yet ) the future of the traditional methods. Also animated similar to this important question 'Return of the Jedi Clone body were! Powerful than his new Master a Midichlorian count that exceeded even Master.!