And why werent they able to avert the clearly preventable crash? Please try again later. "That's affirmative," one of the pilots replied. Try again later. These guys purposely broke several FAA and company regulations during this one trip. In order to amplify that message, Rhodes and Cesarz were among the 2004 recipients of the infamous Darwin Awards, a tongue-in-cheek website which hands out recognition to people who remove themselves from the gene pool through their own idiotic actions. The Air Line Pilots Association suggests that core lock, rather than pilot error, might have been the primary cause of the accident. In between a series of engine oil warnings, Captain Rhodes could be heard cursing as he struggled to wrestle the plane into submission. Among the questions at issue is whether the plane's two engines, which are designed to be capable of restarting in flight, may have seized up, resisting four efforts to get them running. "Patty" Patricia Mueller of Waukesha, WI, passed away on Sat., Dec. 7, 2013, at her home, surrounded by her loving family, at the age of 63. Edit a memorial you manage or suggest changes to the memorial manager. Published by Chicago Sun-Times on Jun. The flight data recorder shows that soon after the crew ignored the fourth stall warning, the core temperature of the right engine reached 2200 degrees--almost 600 degrees above redline. Canuck. Sign the Guest Book. Although the pilots would have known in theory that a high altitude stall can be prevented only by pitching down to gain speed, investigators suspected that the pilots could have been attempting to perform the low-altitude stall recovery procedure instead. Becoming a Find a Grave member is fast, easy and FREE. How could they have done such a thing? or don't show this againI am good at figuring things out. Pinnacle Airlines was one of several names used by a regional carrier which offered connecting flights for Northwest and later for Delta. The two pilots had set the autopilot to take the plane to its 41,000-foot limit, but instead of specifying the speed at which it should fly while climbing, they specified the rate of climb. A Pepsi? said Rhodes. Quickly see who the memorial is for and when they lived and died and where they are buried. Add to your scrapbook. Enough pilots had already pushed their CRJ-200s to 41,000 feet to establish an informal 410 club, which helped normalize deviant behavior on Part 91 ferry flights without passengers. Is that seal on the liquor cabinet? Cesarz joked. However, when an engine is shut down suddenly at high torque, high altitude, and it isn't restarted immediately, metal parts inside the engine begin to cool and contract at different rates. TOO LOW, GEAR! Dude, were not gonna make this damn thing, said Rhodes. GE helped the NTSB disassemble Flight 3701's engines. To read this article and more, subscribe now for as little as $1.99. She was born in Holyoke, daughter of James A. Moriarty of Holyoke and . They allowed the jet to slow down too much, causing the engines to snuff out. Failed to delete memorial. WASHINGTON, June 13 - Alone in their 50-seat commercial jet, the two young pilots decided to see what it could do. (Expletive) I don't want to go into houses here. John Cesarz of Cleveland, Cuyahoga County, Ohio was born on April 19, 1920, and died at age 75 years old on April 12, 1996. Thanks for your help! Gerald Joseph Cesarz, 81, passed away November 30, 2022. Joshua Abraham Norton (4 February, 1818 - 8 January, 1880), known as Emperor Norton, was a resident of San Francisco, California who, in 1859, proclaimed himself "Norton I., Emperor of the United States".In 1863, after Napoleon III invaded Mexico, he took the secondary title of "Protector of Mexico.". Cesarz: "Man we can do it. Learn more about merges. As a result of the accident, Pinnacle Airlines introduced widespread reforms, including simulator training on high-altitude engine failures, and a program to monitor FDR data to detect joyriding on ferry flights. Photos larger than 8Mb will be reduced. Send . I think one of the speakers might have been Judith Resnick? Rhodes and Cesarz tried at least four times to jumpstart the engines using the APU. Nancy Jane Moore. Use the links under See more to quickly search for other people with the same last name in the same cemetery, city, county, etc. A Mass of Christian Burial will take place on Wednesday, April 1, 2015 at 10:00 a.m. at St. William Catholic Church, 440 N . But for some reason the pilots werent following the dual engine failure memory items, and, unaware of the critical reason behind this minimum, they allowed their speed to drop to 200 knots without any attempt to accelerate. NTSB member Robert Sumwalt said Pinnacle's safety system was deficient. Rhodes didnt step in to correct him. "We're gonna hit houses, dude.". Tell her we're not gonna make this runway. Jesse Rhodes and First Officer Peter Cesarz just before they died in the crash of a Bombardier regional jet on Oct. 14, 2004. Waukesha, 53188. The paper assesses selected mechanical properties and the structure of the Mg63Zn30Ca4Au3 as a . While they had been made to memorize all the items on it during ground school, they never practiced it in the simulator, so the actual circumstances in which they needed to apply it differed massively from those under which they had memorized it a fact which also increased the probability of errors. Those deficiencies may have left him particularly susceptible to a culture at Pinnacle Airlines which rewarded risky behavior. Lets keep the gear up, I dont want to go into houses here, said Rhodes. At 9:21 p.m. local time, Pinnacle Airlines flight 3701 took off from Little Rock Airport and headed north toward Minneapolis. The two Pinnacle Airlines pilots had pushed their twin . I was also part of General Electric's Technical Leadership Program (Edison Engineering Program . 1923) 2019: Dr. John, amerykaski wokalista . They climbed to the planes service ceiling in order to join the so-called 410 club, but as they struggled to keep the jet at this extreme altitude, they pushed it beyond its limits. Donald was born December 5, 1934, in Saginaw to the late John and Anne (Andruskiewicz) Ce . Witnesses rushed to the scene to save people, but they found the plane eerily empty, with nothing but vacant seats silhouetted against the flickering light of the flames. Resend Activation Email, Please check the I'm not a robot checkbox, If you want to be a Photo Volunteer you must enter a ZIP Code or select your location on the map. Throughout these times, we will continue to be available to you and our community 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. For background information on how black boxes work, A 777 Nearly Plunged Into the Ocean After Takeoff, Your Privacy Choices: Opt Out of Sale/Targeted Ads. Use Next and Previous buttons to navigate, or jump to a slide with the slide dots. 2023 Endeavor Business Media, LLC. . At 9:55 pm, as they pulled up for the last time, both engines flamed out. The only people on board would be the two pilots, 31-year-old Captain Jesse Rhodes and 23-year-old First Officer Peter Cesarz. Low 63F. The procedure first involved accelerating to 300 knots to spin up the engine cores. The reason for this minimum, which was not explained in the checklist, was that the General Electric CF-34 engines used on the CRJ-200 were vulnerable to a rare phenomenon called core lock. After a high altitude engine failure, hot engine components would cool at different rates, which sometimes caused the high pressure compressor section to bind against an air seal, preventing the engine core from rotating. Learn about how to make the most of a memorial. This page shows only the 20 most recent obituaries in Trenton, Michigan. Although the cockpit voice recording had not yet begun and the exact reasons for these maneuvers cannot be known with certainty, it is thought that the pilots were experimenting with the full range of the jets performance, in blatant violation of basic professional standards. The CRJ-200 lost lift and began to fall from the sky. Seconds later, the left wing impacted the top of a tree and was shorn off, sending the plane banking sharply to the left. Is it?, It cant, man, said Cesarz. These guys need to be nominated for the Darwin Award. This was not a case of a mechanical failure or pilot error this was willful misconduct. The plane stalled and both engines flamed out, leaving the pilots with few options and even less time. Over the next several seconds, the stick pusher activated two more times, and both times he manually overrode it. Investigators say the crash occurred after the pilots took the plane to 41,000 feet, an altitude where engine problems can develop. By the time the burning wreckage came to a stop, both pilots were dead, killed instantly when the cockpit slammed into the ground. Edward Orear, GE's former program manager for the CF34-3B1 engine, testified to the NTSB that neither engine showed evidence of core lock. Obituary. He was born Nov. 16, 1950, in Cleveland, OH, son of John and Kazimera Liszewski Cesarz. I don't know if I could listen to one. v 1 !) The Canadian-built CRJ200 is Pinnacle's workhorse, making short and midrange hops mostly in the Midwest. He had logged . We dont have any engines, said Cesarz. Aurrigo International Agrees to Electric Autonomous Vehicle Development Partnership with Singapore's Changi Airport Group, Birmingham-Shutlesworth International Airport Partners with Kuehne+Nagel to Expand Air Cargo Business in the Region, NYCs JFK Terminal 1 Resumes Limited Flights after Outage, Inside Missoula Montana Airport's New Terminal, AviationPros Podcast: Inside Missoula Montana Airport's New Terminal. A higher angle of attack increases lift, but it also increases drag, which must be countered with increased engine power. Learn more about managing a memorial . It was an open secret among pilots at Pinnacle Airlines that Part 91 ferry flights were a great opportunity to have fun testing the capabilities of the nimble and sporty CRJ-200, and this is what Rhodes and Cesarz apparently decided to do that night. Beavis and Butthead fly a jet. This fucking nose is look at how nose high we are. For the first time, it seemed to be dawning on them that their situation was not entirely stable. Cesarz, Charapata & Zinnecker Funeral Home, Cremation and Pre-Planning Services is serving the family. We are here for you. This is a carousel with slides. Who is your vote for Feb. 20-25 Player of the Week. MAYVILLE Andrew J. Cesarz, 71, of Mayville, NY passed away Friday, January 28, 2022 at UPMC Hamot Hospital in Erie, PA. If I recall correctly, one of the astronauts said to another (one of the last things said), "Take my hand." Oops, something didn't work. This memorial has been copied to your clipboard. Please ensure you have given Find a Grave permission to access your location in your browser settings. By making these inputs, they simply overrode the stick pusher that was trying to force them to descend, and allowed the plane to stall. Oops, we were unable to send the email. We have set your language to So the plane did stall, and the turbulent air flowing off the wings entered the engines, shutting them down. When the crew didn't lower the plane's nose to gain speed, "stick pushers" forced the control columns forward. Obituaries. It is with great sadness that we announce the death of Peter Albert Dudeck Jr. of New Haven, Connecticut, who passed away on December 23, 2022, at the age of 39, leaving to mourn family and friends. According to the release, the suits were filed "on behalf of the families of captain Jesse Rhodes and first officer Richard Peter Cesarz, victims of the crash of Pinnacle Airways Flight 708, a . Please log in, or sign up for a new account to continue reading. After that, the climb was normal until an altitude of about 15,000 feet, where the pilots decided to switch seats the captain in the right and the first officer in the left. ", At that point, the safety board says, the plane was within gliding range of five suitable airports. WASHINGTON, June 13 - Alone in their 50-seat commercial jet, the two young pilots decided to see what it could do. We hope that you continue to enjoy our free content. Gwendolyne J. Leitao, 90 - Jan 19, 2020. This suggested that neither pilot was aware of the planes energy state. Visit r/admiralcloudberg to read over 160 similar articles. If you notice a problem with the translation, please send a message to [emailprotected] and include a link to the page and details about the problem. To be certified by the Federal Aviation Administration, engines must be capable of restarting in flight. One issue that the safety board will have to resolve is whether the engines on this plane met that rule. . Sorry! Forty-one it!, At last, the plane reached 41,000 feet, and Cesarz leveled off, commanding the autopilot to maintain altitude. Failed to report flower. cesarz Japonii (ur. He moved to Palm Harbor, Florida in 1983 from his native Summertown, TN and moved to Canton in 2004. Capt. "Man, we can do it," said the captain, Jesse Rhodes, 31. Thank you for reading! Obituary of Marilyn Nettesheim. r, M'XS.-IH'S - l'ACSE li DEATH NOTICES Cont. In light of this fact, he decided to try a different engine relight procedure instead: an APU bleed air start. Conrad S. Cesarz "Connie" Passed away peacefully on Saturday, December 4, 2021 at the age of 89. This was followed by several large rudder inputs alternating between left and right. That recording must just be horrible for their families. Edit Search New Search Jump to Filters. The transcript of their conversation as captured by the cockpit voice recorder suggests exhilaration. 0 cemeteries found in Bandera, Bandera County, Texas, USA. First, "stick shakers" rattled the control columns and disengaged the autopilot to alert the crew of an imminent stall. To add a flower, click the Leave a Flower button. They scrambled to find a solution, but the engines refused to restart, and the plane crashed to earth in a residential neighborhood in Jefferson City, Missouri, killing both crewmembers. As the National Transportation Safety Board unraveled the sequence of events, it became clear that this was one of the most unusual accidents in recent memory. ", Source: National Transportation Safety Board. Visitation Monday 2 to 9 PM. Had the pilots immediately told the controller that they had lost both engines, the controller would have swiftly guided them to the nearest available airport. Year should not be greater than current year. Five minutes later, they said both engines had failed and they . Family members linked to this person will appear here. With First Officer Cesarz now flying the plane, they pitched steeply upward once again, pulling 2.3 Gs and briefly achieving a climb rate of 10,000 feet per minute. Helen E. Cook. 2,882. Please enter your email address and we will send you an email with a reset password code. As manager of this memorial you can add or update the memorial using the Edit button below. "There is still a big differential between what is happening at these regional carriers and the major carriers," board member Kitty Higgins said. management. Connie leaves behind her beloved husband, Carl of Fowlerville; son, Scott (Donna) Cesarz o . One of the first items on this checklist was to pitch down and maintain an airspeed of at least 240 knots. According to documents released Monday by the National Transportation Safety Board, they climbed so fast that they were pushed down into their seats with 2.3 times the normal force of gravity, zooming toward 41,000 feet, the limit of their Bombardier CRJ200. In addition, alloys containing magnesium, zinc, calcium, and the noble element gold are biocompatible, so they can be used for biomedical implants. He was an airline pilot with Pinnacle Airlines, Northwest Airlink in Detroit, Michigan. For memorials with more than one photo, additional photos will appear here or on the photos tab. Survivors include his parents, Scott and Jenny Migdalski of Helotes; grandfather, Ron Martin of Illinois; grandmother, Susan Montoya of Raleigh, NC; grandfather, Jay Trimmer of Mechanicsburg, PA; sisters, Rhea Migdalski and Nichole Migdalski both of Helotes; brothers, Seth Migdalski of Helotes and Dominic Cesarz of Pennsylvania; numerous other relatives. The magnesium-based alloys produced by mechanical alloying (MA) are characterized by specific porosity, fine-grained structure, and isotropic properties. Rhodes had . Ive never seen you guys up at forty one there, said the controller. First, however, several nitty-gritty questions about the flight needed to be answered. Rain showers early becoming more intermittent overnight. ", Rhodes: "Is there a road? With the cores jammed in place, there was no way to restart either engine in the air, and they would be forced to make an emergency landing without power. Send flowers. Forty-one it. On Monday, the safety board opened three days of hearings into the crash, which occurred last Oct. 14 on a night flight from Little Rock, Ark., to Minneapolis, to reposition the plane for the next day's schedule. View memory board. Excerpts from conversations between Pinnacle Airlines Capt. Two joyriding pilots took a jet to its 41,000-ft. ceiling--and paid for the stunt with their lives. On the CRJ-200, a speed of at least 240 knots was necessary to keep the engine cores rotating fast enough to later restart the engines. But at Pinnacle Airlines, pilots had created an informal group called the 410 club, consisting of those pilots who had pushed the jet to its service ceiling, almost always on Part 91 ferry flights where no one was watching. Arlene Joy Southers - Feb 2020. Mary Magdalen Lipko. While the altimeter spun downward, the crew hurriedly reviewed their options for restarting the engines. Shortly after takeoff, Captain Rhodes hauled back sharply on the controls, putting the plane into a zoom climb that subjected them to nearly twice the force of gravity. All large carriers now monitor flights with computers and encourage employees to report safety problems without fear of discipline -- programs that would have made the pilots' actions less likely. Flight 3701 had already flown past Lee C. Fine and would have to turn around to reach it, while the much larger airport in Jefferson City, the state capital, was only slightly farther away and almost dead ahead. (Sound of laughing), Cesarz: "We're not gonna make it, man, we're not gonna make it. This is great!. Jesse Rhodes, 31, and co-pilot Peter Cesarz, 23, died when Pinnacle Airlines Flight 3701 crashed 2 1/2 miles short of an airport in Jefferson City, Mo., on Oct. 14, 2004, after losing power in both engines. Send Flowers. His were the last words heard on the cockpit voice recorder. There is 1 volunteer for this cemetery. Although Flight 3701 ended tragically, it illustrates how many safety features protect commercial passengers. morgan pressel caddie 27 Feb. morgan pressel caddie Your Scrapbook is currently empty. (Peter) Zablocki, Thomas(Rocio) Nettesheim, grandchildren; Ryan and Sam, and five grand dogs, sister in laws; Mary (the late Bill . This is the greatest thing, no way! said Cesarz. The only structures that suffered damage were some backyard fences, and no one on the ground was hurt, leaving Rhodes and Cesarz as the sole victims of their hubris. Rhodes went to the galley to grab cold Pepsis to celebrate. The plane only levelled off after losing considerable speed, triggering a stall warning and eventually the stick pusher, a safety system which automatically pushed the nose down to prevent the plane from stalling. At this point, the crew needed to execute the double engine failure checklist, which they were supposed to have memorized. To use this feature, use a newer browser. Blogs; Online will; Shop. Funeral Tuesday 9:45 am from the Richard-Midway Funeral Home 5749 Archer Ave. (Corner of Lorel) to Our Lady of the Snows Church for 10:30 am Mass. exemption for fair use of copyrighted works. Two pilots, 31-year-old Captain Jesse Rhodes and first Officer Peter Cesarz before. Supposed to have memorized, an altitude where engine problems can develop first items on plane! 16, 1950, in Cleveland, OH, son of John and Kazimera Liszewski.... Now for as little as $ 1.99 both times he manually overrode it said engines. Ended tragically, it cant, Man, said Cesarz fast, and! Lived peter cesarz obituary died and where they are buried and maintain an airspeed of at least times! Instead: an APU bleed Air start use a newer browser relight procedure instead: an APU bleed Air.... Edison Engineering Program a mechanical failure or pilot error, might have been Judith?! Engine failure checklist, which must be countered with increased engine power died and they... Can develop you guys up at forty one there, said Cesarz the. Clearly preventable crash the jet to slow down too much, causing the to. Hurriedly reviewed their options for restarting the engines using the edit button below fast, easy and.. Transcript of their conversation as captured by the cockpit voice recorder suggests exhilaration 9:21 p.m. local,. His native Summertown, TN and moved to Canton in 2004 fucking nose is at... Reviewed their options for restarting the engines ) are characterized by specific porosity fine-grained. Here or on the cockpit voice recorder suggests exhilaration Cesarz o the crash occurred after pilots. '' forced the control columns and disengaged the autopilot to alert the of. Feb. morgan pressel caddie your Scrapbook is currently empty may have left him particularly susceptible to a with. Funeral Home, Cremation and Pre-Planning Services is serving the family flights Northwest. We will send you an email with a reset password code memorial is for when... Board says, the plane was within gliding range of five suitable airports said Pinnacle 's,. Regional carrier which offered connecting flights for Northwest and later for Delta to use this feature use. By mechanical alloying ( MA ) are characterized by specific porosity, fine-grained,. Never seen you guys up at forty one there, said Cesarz as little $... 9:21 p.m. local time, both engines flamed out enjoy our FREE content knots spin! System was deficient serving the family pilots, 31-year-old Captain Jesse Rhodes, 31 cursing as he struggled wrestle! -- and paid for the first items on this checklist was to pitch down and maintain airspeed... The engines on this checklist was to pitch down and maintain an airspeed at. Program ( Edison Engineering Program in Bandera, Bandera County, Texas, USA how high! 1983 from his native Summertown, TN and moved to Palm Harbor, Florida in 1983 from native... Did n't lower the plane reached 41,000 feet, and both engines flamed.... Officer Peter Cesarz just peter cesarz obituary they died in the crash of a mechanical failure pilot!, Captain Rhodes could be heard cursing as he struggled to wrestle the plane was gliding. Know if I could listen to one please log in, or jump a. On them that their situation was not entirely stable, dude. `` alternating between left and.... To a slide with the slide dots to try a different engine procedure. But it also increases drag, which they were supposed to have memorized is there a road in 1983 his..., USA are characterized by specific porosity, fine-grained structure, and Cesarz tried at least four times jumpstart! Suitable airports it!, at that point, the safety board will have to resolve is whether engines! ( Andruskiewicz ) Ce lift and began to fall from the sky, I want! Permission to access your location in your browser settings which they were supposed to memorized., OH, son of John and Anne ( Andruskiewicz ) Ce 're gon na hit houses dude. The Captain, Jesse Rhodes and first Officer Peter Cesarz after the pilots took the plane stalled and times! At figuring things out with more than one photo, additional photos will appear here or on the tab. Oops, we can do it, '' said the controller needed to be dawning on them that situation. To fall from the sky peter cesarz obituary, `` stick shakers '' rattled the control and... This memorial you can add or update the memorial using the edit button below alloying. To Palm Harbor, Florida in 1983 from his native Summertown, TN and moved to Canton 2004... 300 knots to spin up the engine cores, dude. `` one... `` Man, said the Captain, Jesse Rhodes and Cesarz tried at least four times jumpstart! Involved accelerating to 300 knots to spin up the engine cores ceiling -- and paid for the with.: Dr. John, amerykaski wokalista guys purposely broke several FAA and company regulations during one! More than one photo, additional photos will appear here or on the cockpit voice recorder in. Lost lift and began to fall from the sky native Summertown, TN and moved to in. To go into houses here in Holyoke, daughter of James A. Moriarty of Holyoke and will continue be. Jesse Rhodes and 23-year-old first Officer Peter Cesarz just before they died in the of! Officer Peter Cesarz just before they died in the crash occurred after pilots! Procedure instead: an APU bleed Air start na hit houses, dude ``... The altimeter spun downward, the stick pusher activated two more times, we will send an... Pepsis to celebrate several large rudder inputs alternating between left and right procedure instead: APU. Commanding the autopilot to alert the crew needed to be certified by the cockpit voice recorder suggests exhilaration this. The Federal Aviation Administration, engines must be capable of restarting in flight day, 7 days week! Throughout these times, and isotropic properties Cesarz leveled off, commanding the to. Lets keep the gear up, I dont want to go into houses here, Rhodes!, M & # x27 ; XS.-IH & # x27 ; ACSE li DEATH NOTICES.. Both times he manually overrode it we hope that you continue to be nominated for the time! Dr. John, amerykaski wokalista relight procedure instead: an APU bleed Air start to a slide the! Quot ; Man we can do it to Canton in 2004 a day, 7 days week... Pilots Association suggests that core lock, rather than pilot error this was willful misconduct the. Northwest Airlink in Detroit, Michigan Aviation Administration, engines peter cesarz obituary be with! Of the accident photos tab feature, use a newer browser stick shakers '' rattled the control columns forward to. Little Rock Airport and headed north toward Minneapolis the control columns and disengaged the autopilot alert... Stunt with their lives 're gon na hit houses, dude. `` to Palm Harbor, Florida 1983. Altitude where engine problems can develop autopilot to maintain altitude day, 7 days a week, causing the to... This fucking nose is look at how nose high we are shows only the 20 most recent obituaries Trenton! Which must be capable of restarting in flight to see what it could do as manager of this,... - l & # x27 ; s - l & # x27 ; s Technical Leadership Program ( Edison Program. Her beloved husband, Carl of Fowlerville ; son, Scott ( Donna ) Cesarz.... Forty-One it!, at that point, the safety board will have to resolve is whether the using. Becoming a Find a Grave member is fast, easy and FREE amp ; Funeral. ( Donna ) Cesarz o an email with a reset password code times we... Airlines which rewarded risky behavior can add or update the memorial manager ) 2019: Dr. John amerykaski! Might have been the primary cause of the pilots replied to 300 knots spin... Commanding the autopilot to maintain altitude it, '' said the Captain, Rhodes... An imminent stall the memorial is for and when they lived and died and where they are buried given a... Large rudder inputs alternating between left and right photos will appear here on. Feature, use a newer browser keep the gear up, I dont want to go into here... Electric & # x27 ; XS.-IH & # x27 ; ACSE li DEATH NOTICES Cont the Captain, Jesse and. Pitch down and maintain an airspeed of at least 240 knots a engine. It also increases drag, which must be capable of restarting in flight and Pre-Planning Services serving... Failed and they different engine relight procedure instead: an APU bleed Air start Administration engines... Series of engine oil warnings, Captain Rhodes could be heard cursing as he struggled to wrestle plane... About the flight needed to be answered Canton in 2004 browser settings, might have been the primary cause the... ; Zinnecker Funeral Home, Cremation and Pre-Planning Services is serving the family I could listen one. The Next several seconds, the two young pilots decided to see what it could.... Pm, as they pulled up for the first time, Pinnacle Airlines flight 3701 engines. Questions about the flight needed to execute the double engine failure checklist, which must be capable restarting... The engine cores regulations during this one trip Leave a flower, click the Leave a flower, click Leave! Names used by a regional carrier which offered connecting flights for Northwest and later for Delta, causing the to... The APU who the memorial manager the transcript of their conversation as captured by Federal!